| Platinum | Bertucci's Italian Restaurant |
| Platinum | Johnny Macaronis |
| Gold | Tutto Bene |
| Silver | The Chateau |
| Bronze | Lindos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amelia's |
| Top Pick | Corfinio Italian Wood Fired Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Little Sami's |
| Top Pick | Mia Regazza |
