| Platinum | Village Pizza & Subs |
| Gold | Bertucci's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Cape Cod Cafe Pizza |
| Bronze | Home Cafe |
| Top Pick | Classic Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lynwood Cafe |
| Top Pick | Summit's Place |
| Top Pick | Supreme Pizza and Subs |
| Top Pick | Tinray's Pizza Cafe |
| Top Pick | West Side Pizza & Sub Shop |
